Evil score and justice calculationn for Falsifying Registration Applications

  Here is the case 

[Oklahoma City Manager Arrested on 11 Felony Voter Fraud Charges After Falsifying Registration Applications With Other People’s Names]

Quick clarification first: this story is about the city manager of Mannsville, Oklahoma (not Oklahoma City). Local outlets report that Mannsville’s city manager, Shonda Lou Barnes, was arrested on Aug 31, 2026, on 11 counts of False Affidavit in Voter Registration after allegedly submitting applications with signatures that didn’t match the real applicants. (kxii.com)

Evil score (0–20)

• Evasion/irrationality: 4 — sustained, deliberate falsification.
• Method corruption/dishonesty: 4 — creating/filing fraudulent registrations.
• Hierarchy betrayal: 4 — abuse of public trust by a city official to distort an election process.
• Rights violation (fraud as coercion’s cognitive equivalent): 3 — attacks citizens’ voting rights via deceit.
• Magnitude/scope of harm: 2 — 11 falsified registrations; serious but not yet shown to have altered actual votes/outcomes.
• 
  Total: 17/20 → Major evil.

Justice calculation (SSS) assuming the allegations are true and provable

• Type (T): Fraud against the electoral process → T2 = 2.
• Mens rea (M): Intentional/purposeful → 1.5.
• Harm (H): Moderate (no proven illegal votes cast yet) → +1.
• Pattern (P): Repeated conduct (11 counts) → +1.
• Aggravators (A): Abuse of public trust/leadership role → +3.
• Mitigators (K): none known → 0.
• 
  SSS = (T × M × 4) + H + P + A − K = (2 × 1.5 × 4) + 1 + 1 + 3 − 0 = 17.
• 
  Band: 17–22 → long confinement; major monetary penalties; bans from positions of trust.

Statutory penalty anchors in Oklahoma

• Each count appears to fall under Title 26 “False affidavit in voter registration,” a felony offense. Oklahoma’s updated election code classifies such election fraud as a Class D1 felony. (oklahoma.gov)
• Class D1 felony punishment: up to 5 years’ imprisonment per conviction, with at least 20% of the sentence to be served before release; courts may also impose fines (Title 21 §20N; Title 26 §16‑101 authorizes fines up to $50,000 per conviction for D1 election felonies). Whether sentences run concurrently or consecutively is up to the court. (law.justia.com)
• On conviction, a public officer/employee is suspended and then must vacate the position; when the felony relates to office duties, forfeiture of office benefits may apply (51 O.S. §24.1). That would remove her from city employment and bar her from continuing in that role. (law.justia.com)

Recommended penalty package (consistent with SSS 17)

• Criminal: Active incarceration within the D1 range; consider consecutive time for multiple counts if the court finds a scheme; fine(s) consistent with Title 26 §16‑101. (govt.westlaw.com)
• Professional: Immediate suspension; on conviction, removal from office and disqualification/benefit forfeiture as applicable under 51 O.S. §24.1; multi‑year ban from any role involving election administration or public trust. (law.justia.com)
• Compliance/integrity remedies: Court order prohibiting contact with election records/processes; required compliance program and audits if any municipal office procedures were implicated.

Escalation/mitigation notes

• If any fraudulent registrations led to ballots issued or votes cast, raise Harm to H3 (+2) → SSS ≈ 18–19 (higher in-band penalties). If linked to altering outcomes or a broader organized scheme, consider P2 (+2) and higher A, pushing SSS 20+. (kxii.com)
• Mitigators (cooperation, early plea, full disclosure of methods) could reduce A or add K, nudging SSS toward 15–16.

Sources

• Local reporting on the arrest and count details. (kxii.com)
• Oklahoma election felonies and penalties (Title 26; D1 classification and fines). (govt.westlaw.com)
• Class D1 sentencing framework (max 5 years; 20% service). (law.justia.com)
• Office forfeiture on felony conviction for public officers/employees. (law.justia.com)

---

Learn more:

1. Mannsville city manager arrested on voter registration fraud charges
2. <table id="e1">
3. Oklahoma Statutes §21-20N (2024) - Class D1 offenses. :: 2024 Oklahoma Statutes :: U.S. Codes and Statutes :: U.S. Law :: Justia
4. Oklahoma Statutes §51-24.1 (2025) - Suspension or forfeiture of office or employment upon conviction of felony - Vacancy - Salary and benefits - Governor notified in writing. :: 2025 Oklahoma Statutes :: U.S. Codes and Statutes :: U.S. Law :: Justia
5. View Document - Official Oklahoma Statutes (Unannotated)