Objective law concerning free speech and hate speech

First: Definition of Objective LawAn "objective law" is a principle (genus) that accurately describes a recurring pattern of behavior or interaction in reality, derived from the inherent properties or causal relationships of the entities involved, applies universally within its defined scope, is logically consistent, and enables reliable predictions (differentia).
Essential Characteristics:

• Describes an observable, recurring pattern of behavior or interaction.
• Based on the entities, attributes, and actions as they exist in reality.
• Arises from the inherent properties or causal relationships of entities.
• Contains logically consistent, non-contradictory content.
• Applies universally to the entities or interactions within its scope.
• Enables reliable predictions when its conditions are met.

This definition ensures that objective laws are grounded in reality, free from arbitrary or subjective influences, and provide a stable framework for understanding and predicting outcomes.Next: Objective Laws Regarding Free SpeechIn an objective legal system, free speech is a fundamental principle rooted in the recognition of individual rights. Objective law protects the right of individuals to express their thoughts, ideas, and opinions without government interference or censorship, provided the speech does not meet the legal threshold for direct incitement to imminent violence, fraud, defamation, or other clear violations of individual rights (e.g., targeted threats). This protection reflects the observable reality that humans rely on the free exchange of ideas to exercise reason, discover truth, and pursue individual flourishing.
Laws restricting hate speech or offensive speech would generally be invalid in an objective legal system unless they involve direct violations of others’ rights, such as targeted harassment or true threats. The focus remains on safeguarding individual rights rather than controlling speech based on its content or perceived offensiveness. By prioritizing free expression, an objective legal system ensures that all individuals are equally protected in their right to speak, regardless of the views they express, fostering open discourse essential to a free society.In Addition: Broader Implications of Free SpeechIn an objective legal system, free speech is essential for the flourishing of individuals and society. The right to express thoughts and opinions is a natural extension of the human capacity for reason and autonomous judgment. Objective law primarily protects against government censorship, ensuring individuals can speak without fear of state coercion. While private entities may moderate speech on their own platforms or properties, consistent with their property rights, an objective legal system ensures access to open forums for expression and protects individuals from coercive suppression of lawful speech in public spaces.The system balances free expression with accountability for speech that directly violates others’ rights, such as defamation, fraud, perjury, or extortion. This ensures that individuals can freely express themselves while respecting the rights of others. Free speech is a cornerstone of a rational society, enabling individuals to challenge prevailing ideas, innovate, and pursue truth without fear of coercion. While some argue that restricting hate speech promotes societal harmony, an objective legal system recognizes that suppressing speech risks undermining the rational discourse necessary for a free and flourishing society.Overall, objective law concerning free speech creates a framework where individuals can engage in open, honest discourse, challenge dogma, and pursue knowledge in accordance with their values and beliefs, fostering a society grounded in reason and individual autonomy.