In the conservative view, the United States owes its primary political, legal, and fiscal obligations to its citizens, and those obligations should not be diluted by or redirected to individuals who are in the country unlawfully. This reflects core principles of national sovereignty, the rule of law, accountability to the citizenry, and fairness to legal immigrants who followed the rules.
How that primacy shows up in policy from a conservative perspective:
- Political rights: Voting, office-holding, and federal jury service are reserved to citizens; conservatives oppose any effort to extend voting to noncitizens and reject policies that would amplify political power based on unlawful presence.
- Public benefits: Taxpayer-funded benefits should be limited to citizens and, where permitted by law, certain lawful residents—not those here illegally—while ensuring emergency care and humanitarian obligations are met.
- Employment: Enforce laws against hiring unauthorized workers (e.g., universal E-Verify), deter identity fraud, and penalize employers who undercut citizen and lawful workers by exploiting illegal labor.
- Law enforcement and border security: Secure the border, end catch‑and‑release, tighten asylum and parole abuse, oppose sanctuary policies, and prioritize removal of criminal aliens—with full due process as required by law.
- Respect for legal immigrants and the rule of law: Prioritize those who follow the rules, encourage assimilation, civic education, and English proficiency, and align immigration with the national interest.
Important legal caveat: Conservatives also recognize that the Constitution protects “persons” with due process and equal protection, so basic rights and humane treatment apply to everyone. But citizenship carries unique political rights and claims on public resources that should take precedence over those who violate immigration laws.
In addition:
Here’s a fuller, conservative-aligned overview of what “citizen primacy” means in policy terms and how it’s typically implemented:
Core principles
- Sovereignty and the rule of law: A nation owes its first duties to its citizens; immigration policy should deter unlawful entry and residence, not normalize it or reward it. [1]
- Fairness to lawful immigrants and taxpayers: Public resources and pathways should favor those who follow the rules, while discouraging incentives for illegal entry. [2]
- Equal dignity with due process: While citizens have unique political rights and claims on public resources, the Constitution protects all “persons,” so humane treatment and due process apply to everyone. [3]
Border security and enforcement
- Secure the border: Expand physical barriers where effective, modern surveillance, and personnel; end catch-and-release by using detention or swift alternatives with real consequences for no‑shows. [4]
- Tighten asylum and parole: Restore a high, credible-fear threshold, curb abuse of humanitarian parole to narrow, case-by-case uses, and pursue “safe third country” or “remain in country/region” approaches to process claims outside the U.S. interior. [5]
- Expedited removal and interior enforcement: Use expedited removal for recent unlawful entrants, reinstate firm removal priorities that include criminal aliens and repeat immigration violators, and strengthen cooperation among DHS components. [6]
State and local cooperation
- End sanctuary policies: Encourage or require local jurisdictions to honor lawful federal detainers and share information; tie certain grants to cooperation to prevent shielding criminal aliens. [1]
- 287(g) partnerships: Expand agreements that allow trained local officers to assist with immigration screening in jails and during targeted operations. [2]
Labor market integrity
- Universal E-Verify: Mandate E-Verify nationwide to protect citizen and lawful workers from wage undercutting and identity theft; pair with strong penalties for knowing violations. [3]
- Fight document and identity fraud: Resource investigations into stolen or synthetic identities used for unlawful employment; hold bad-actor employers accountable. [4]
Public benefits and fiscal prioritization
- Limit taxpayer-funded benefits to citizens and eligible lawful residents: Follow the general rule that illegal aliens are ineligible for most federal means-tested benefits, while meeting emergency and humanitarian obligations required by law. [5]
- Oppose state-level benefits that create magnets: Resist in‑state tuition, driver’s licenses, and other subsidies for illegal aliens that can draw more unlawful migration. [6]
Civic and political rights
- Voting reserved to citizens: Maintain the bedrock norm that only U.S. citizens vote in federal and state elections; oppose local experiments with noncitizen voting that blur citizen primacy. [1]
- Election integrity measures: Support proof-of-citizenship and robust list maintenance to ensure only eligible citizens are on the rolls. [2]
Legal immigration aligned with the national interest
- Merit-based emphasis: Shift toward skills, English proficiency, and economic contributions, while keeping a reasonable, focused humanitarian program that does not overwhelm vetting or integration capacity. [3]
- Support assimilation: Promote civic education and English acquisition so newcomers embrace American norms and responsibilities. [4]
Humanity and constitutional safeguards
- Due process and humane treatment: Ensure custody standards, access to counsel where applicable, medical care, and protection from trafficking and abuse, consistent with constitutional and statutory requirements. [5]
- Protect children while discouraging fraud: Maintain safeguards for minors and families while closing loopholes that incentivize recycling, fake family claims, or dangerous journeys. [6]
Practical steps conservatives often prioritize
- Codify limits on broad, programmatic parole and tighten asylum standards to reduce abuse. [1]
- Fund more immigration judges and asylum officers to speed lawful adjudications and removals. [2]
- Make E-Verify mandatory with phased implementation for small businesses and strong anti-fraud tools. [3]
- Condition certain federal grants on cooperation with federal immigration enforcement to end sanctuary practices. [4]
- Restore and expand 287(g), Secure Communities, and targeted interior enforcement against criminal aliens and repeat violators. [5]
- Clarify benefit eligibility to prevent cost-shifting to citizens and lawful residents, while preserving emergency and humanitarian care. [6]
Bottom line: A conservative approach prioritizes the interests, security, and economic well-being of American citizens and lawful immigrants, while maintaining humane treatment and constitutional protections for all persons. It rewards compliance with the law, removes incentives for illegal entry, and aligns immigration with the national interest rather than with unlawful presence. [1][2][3][4][5][6]
No comments:
Post a Comment