Empiricism: New Year's resolutions that are realistic and sustainable

 Here is information about crafting New Year's resolutions that are realistic and sustainable. Below, I'll provide a comprehensive summary of empirical data and studies related to New Year's resolutions, focusing on why people often fail to keep them, what types of resolutions are more likely to succeed, and specific, actionable resolutions that research suggests can be maintained long-term.

---

Empirical Data on New Year's Resolutions: Success Rates and Challenges

1. Success Rates of Resolutions:

   • A study by Norcross et al. (2002) published in the Journal of Clinical Psychology found that only about 8% of people successfully achieve their New Year's resolutions by the end of the year. Approximately 25% of individuals abandon their resolutions within the first week, and over 50% fail by the six-month mark.
   • The same study highlighted that individuals who explicitly set New Year's resolutions are 10 times more likely to achieve their goals compared to those who do not set specific resolutions, indicating the importance of intentional goal-setting.

2. Reasons for Failure:

   • Research by Gollwitzer and Sheeran (2006) in Psychological Bulletin suggests that many resolutions fail due to a lack of implementation intentions (specific "if-then" plans). Without a clear plan on how to handle obstacles, individuals are more likely to give up when faced with challenges.
   • A study by Milkman et al. (2008) in Management Science points to "present bias," where individuals prioritize short-term gratification over long-term benefits, as a key reason for abandoning resolutions like exercise or healthy eating.
   • Unrealistic goals are another major factor. According to a study by Marlatt and Kaplan (1972) in Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, overly ambitious or vague goals (e.g., "get fit") often lead to discouragement when progress is not immediate or measurable.

3. Factors for Success:

   • Norcross et al. (1989) found that successful resolvers often use strategies like stimulus control (removing temptations), reinforcement (rewarding small wins), and social support (sharing goals with friends or family).
   • A 2017 study by Oscarsson et al. published in PLoS ONE demonstrated that approach-oriented goals (e.g., "I will start walking daily") are more likely to succeed than avoidance-oriented goals (e.g., "I will stop eating junk food"). Positive framing increases motivation and reduces feelings of deprivation.
   • The concept of "habit stacking," supported by research from Lally et al. (2009) in European Journal of Social Psychology, shows that tying a new habit to an existing routine (e.g., brushing teeth followed by a 5-minute stretch) significantly increases adherence. On average, it takes 66 days for a new behavior to become automatic, though this varies by individual and complexity of the habit.

---

Characteristics of Sustainable New Year's Resolutions

Based on the empirical data, successful resolutions tend to have the following traits:

• Specificity: Goals should be clear and measurable (e.g., "Walk 10,000 steps daily" instead of "Be more active").
• Realism: Goals should be achievable within one’s current lifestyle and resources. Overly ambitious goals lead to burnout.
• Incremental Progress: Breaking goals into smaller, manageable steps helps maintain motivation, as shown by research on self-efficacy by Bandura (1997) in Self-Efficacy: The Exercise of Control.
• Positive Framing: Focusing on adding positive behaviors rather than restricting negative ones boosts adherence.
• Accountability: Sharing goals with others or tracking progress (e.g., via apps or journals) increases commitment, per a 2015 study by Harkin et al. in Psychological Bulletin.

---

Recommended New Year's Resolutions Backed by Research

Here are some specific, evidence-based New Year's resolutions that people are more likely to succeed at and maintain over time. Each suggestion is grounded in empirical findings and designed to be realistic and sustainable.

1. Daily Movement (Walking or Light Exercise):

   • Why It Works: A 2019 meta-analysis by Kelly and Barker in BMJ Open found that even small increases in physical activity (e.g., walking 10 minutes daily) significantly improve health outcomes like cardiovascular health and mood. Starting small reduces intimidation and builds momentum.
   • How to Succeed: Set a specific goal like "Walk 5,000 steps daily" (using a smartphone or pedometer to track). Tie it to an existing habit, such as walking after dinner. Research by Blumenthal et al. (2012) in Psychosomatic Medicine shows consistency matters more than intensity for long-term adherence.
   • Evidence: Lally et al. (2009) found that simple physical activities become habitual faster than complex ones, with walking often becoming automatic within 50-70 days.

2. Mindful Eating (Small Dietary Adjustments):

   • Why It Works: Instead of restrictive diets, small changes like adding one serving of vegetables daily are more sustainable. A 2016 study by Spring et al. in Annals of Behavioral Medicine found that micro-goals in eating habits lead to better long-term outcomes than drastic overhauls.
   • How to Succeed: Focus on approach goals, such as "I will eat one fruit with breakfast every day." Use visual cues (e.g., keeping fruit on the counter) to reinforce the habit, as supported by stimulus control research by Norcross et al. (1989).
   • Evidence: A 2020 study by Gardner et al. in International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity showed that incremental dietary changes are maintained longer than "all-or-nothing" diet plans.

3. Daily Gratitude or Journaling:

   • Why It Works: Practicing gratitude has been linked to improved mental health and life satisfaction. A 2003 study by Emmons and McCullough in Journal of Personality and Social Psychology found that writing down three things one is grateful for daily increases well-being and reduces depressive symptoms.
   • How to Succeed: Set a specific time (e.g., before bed) to write down 1-3 positive experiences or things you’re thankful for. Keep it short (2-5 minutes) to avoid feeling burdened. Habit stacking with bedtime routines enhances consistency.
   • Evidence: Research by Seligman et al. (2005) in American Psychologist showed that gratitude exercises have lasting effects on happiness when done consistently for as little as one month.

4. Improved Sleep Hygiene:

   • Why It Works: Better sleep improves mood, productivity, and physical health. A 2017 study by Walker and van der Helm in Nature Reviews Neuroscience highlights that even small improvements in sleep routines (e.g., consistent bedtime) have significant benefits.
   • How to Succeed: Set a specific bedtime and create a pre-sleep routine (e.g., no screens 30 minutes before bed). Start with one change, like dimming lights in the evening, to make it manageable. The National Sleep Foundation (2020) recommends incremental adjustments over drastic changes.
   • Evidence: A 2018 study by Irish et al. in Sleep Medicine Reviews found that consistent sleep schedules are more achievable and effective than sporadic efforts to "catch up" on sleep.

5. Learning a Micro-Skill (Short, Daily Practice):

   • Why It Works: Learning something new in small doses boosts confidence and cognitive health. A 2014 study by Park et al. in Psychological Science found that engaging in novel, manageable activities (e.g., learning a new word daily) improves memory and motivation.
   • How to Succeed: Choose a simple skill, like learning one new vocabulary word or practicing a 5-minute language app session daily. Tie it to a routine, such as morning coffee. Small, consistent efforts prevent overwhelm.
   • Evidence: Research by Duckworth et al. (2011) in Journal of Personality and Social Psychology on grit shows that persistence in small, daily tasks builds long-term resilience and success.

6. Social Connection (Regular Check-Ins):

   • Why It Works: Strong social ties are linked to better mental and physical health. A 2010 meta-analysis by Holt-Lunstad et al. in PLoS Medicine found that social connection is as critical to longevity as avoiding smoking.
   • How to Succeed: Commit to reaching out to one friend or family member weekly via call or text. Schedule it on a specific day (e.g., Sunday evenings) to build a habit. Keep it low-effort to avoid stress.
   • Evidence: A 2019 study by Dunbar in Journal of Social and Personal Relationships shows that even brief, regular interactions with loved ones sustain emotional well-being.

---

Practical Tips for Sticking to Resolutions

Based on the studies cited, here are additional strategies to enhance success:

• Track Progress: Use a simple app, calendar, or notebook to mark daily progress. A 2015 meta-analysis by Harkin et al. in Psychological Bulletin found that monitoring behavior increases goal attainment by 1.5 times.
• Reward Small Wins: Celebrate milestones (e.g., one week of walking) with non-sabotaging rewards (e.g., a favorite movie night). Reinforcement theory, as discussed by Skinner (1953) in Science and Human Behavior, supports this approach.
• Prepare for Setbacks: Create "if-then" plans for obstacles (e.g., "If I miss a walk due to rain, then I’ll do a 10-minute indoor stretch"). Gollwitzer’s (1999) research on implementation intentions shows this doubles success rates.
• Leverage Social Support: Share goals with a friend or join a community. A 2021 study by Carr et al. in Health Psychology found that accountability partners increase adherence by 65%.

---

Conclusion

New Year's resolutions can be powerful tools for self-improvement, but their success hinges on setting realistic, specific, and positively framed goals. Empirical data consistently shows that small, incremental changes—such as daily walking, mindful eating adjustments, gratitude journaling, better sleep routines, micro-skill learning, and regular social check-ins—are more sustainable than grandiose promises. Studies like Norcross et al. (2002), Oscarsson et al. (2017), and Lally et al. (2009) emphasize the importance of habit formation, specific planning, and social support in maintaining these resolutions over time.

By focusing on one or two of the suggested resolutions and applying evidence-based strategies like habit stacking and progress tracking, individuals can significantly increase their chances of success.

In addition:

Here is more information on the topic of New Year's resolutions with additional empirical data, insights, and a few more sustainable resolution ideas. I'll also build on the previous summary by including further studies and practical strategies to ensure long-term success. Below is a comprehensive update with new information, additional resolutions, and deeper insights into making resolutions stick.

---

Additional Empirical Data on New Year's Resolutions

1. Longitudinal Insights on Resolution Success:

   • A follow-up study by Norcross and Vangarelli (1988) published in Addictive Behaviors tracked resolution-makers over two years and found that self-efficacy (belief in one’s ability to succeed) was a stronger predictor of success than the type of goal. Individuals who maintained confidence, even after setbacks, were more likely to persist.
   • A 2020 study by Klein et al. in Motivation and Emotion revealed that "process-oriented" goals (focusing on the journey, e.g., "I will enjoy cooking healthy meals") rather than "outcome-oriented" goals (focusing on results, e.g., "I will lose 10 pounds") lead to higher satisfaction and adherence rates.

2. Behavioral Economics and Commitment Devices:

   • Research by Bryan, Karlan, and Nelson (2010) in Annual Review of Economics highlights the effectiveness of commitment devices—strategies that "lock in" future behavior. For example, setting up automatic savings transfers or making public commitments can increase follow-through by creating external accountability or financial incentives.
   • A 2014 study by Milkman et al. in Psychological Science introduced the concept of "temptation bundling," where a desirable activity (e.g., listening to a favorite podcast) is paired with a resolution behavior (e.g., exercising on a treadmill). This significantly boosted participation in the target behavior.

3. The Role of Identity in Resolutions:

   • A 2016 study by Walton and Cohen in Journal of Experimental Psychology found that framing resolutions as part of one’s identity (e.g., "I am someone who reads daily") rather than a task (e.g., "I will read more") fosters greater commitment. Identity-based motivation helps individuals internalize behaviors as part of who they are.

4. Timing and Fresh Start Effect:

   • Research by Dai, Milkman, and Riis (2014) in Management Science explored the "fresh start effect," showing that temporal landmarks like New Year’s Day, birthdays, or even the start of a new month can boost motivation for change. People feel a psychological reset at these points, making them more likely to initiate and stick to goals if they capitalize on this momentum early.

---

Expanded Insights on Why Resolutions Fail and How to Counteract It

Building on the earlier summary, here are additional reasons for failure and evidence-based countermeasures:

• Lack of Intrinsic Motivation: A 2012 meta-analysis by Ryan and Deci in Psychological Inquiry on Self-Determination Theory (SDT) found that resolutions driven by external pressures (e.g., societal expectations) rather than internal desires (e.g., personal values) are less likely to succeed. Countermeasure: Reflect on why a goal matters to you personally before committing.
• All-or-Nothing Mindset: A 2018 study by Woolley and Fishbach in Journal of Consumer Research showed that people often abandon goals after a single lapse, viewing it as total failure. Countermeasure: Adopt a "progress, not perfection" mindset, focusing on getting back on track after slip-ups, as supported by relapse prevention research by Marlatt and Donovan (2005) in Assessment of Addictive Behaviors.
• Cognitive Overload: Trying to change too many behaviors at once can overwhelm mental resources. A 2019 study by Baumeister and Vohs in Current Directions in Psychological Science on ego depletion suggests willpower is a finite resource. Countermeasure: Focus on one resolution at a time, or stagger multiple goals over the year.

---

Additional New Year's Resolutions Backed by Research

Here are three more realistic, sustainable resolutions that complement the ones provided earlier. Each is grounded in empirical evidence and designed for long-term adherence.

1. Reduce Digital Overload (Screen Time Limits):

   • Why It Works: Excessive screen time is linked to stress, poor sleep, and reduced productivity. A 2021 study by Twenge and Campbell in Emotion found that limiting recreational screen time to 1-2 hours daily significantly improves mental well-being, especially for adolescents and adults under 35.
   • How to Succeed: Set a specific daily limit (e.g., 1 hour of social media) using phone apps like Screen Time (iOS) or Digital Wellbeing (Android). Replace screen time with an alternative activity, like reading or a hobby, to fill the void. Start with small reductions (e.g., 15 minutes less per day) to avoid frustration.
   • Evidence: Research by Hunt et al. (2018) in Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology showed that reducing social media use by just 30 minutes daily led to measurable decreases in anxiety and loneliness after three weeks.

2. Practice Micro-Acts of Kindness:

   • Why It Works: Small acts of kindness (e.g., complimenting someone, holding a door) boost happiness for both the giver and receiver. A 2017 study by Rowland and Curry in Journal of Experimental Social Psychology found that performing one kind act daily for a week increased life satisfaction and reduced stress.
   • How to Succeed: Commit to one small act of kindness per day, such as sending a thoughtful text or helping a neighbor. Keep it simple and tie it to daily interactions to make it habitual. Documenting these acts (e.g., in a journal) can reinforce the behavior.
   • Evidence: A 2020 meta-analysis by Hui et al. in Psychological Bulletin confirmed that prosocial behaviors, even when small, have a cumulative positive effect on mental health over time.

3. Financial Mindfulness (Small Savings Goals):

   • Why It Works: Financial stress is a major source of anxiety, and small savings habits can build security. A 2016 study by Lusardi and Mitchell in Journal of Economic Literature found that even saving $1-$5 weekly improves financial literacy and reduces stress over time.
   • How to Succeed: Set a micro-goal, like saving $2 per day by cutting one unnecessary expense (e.g., a coffee). Automate savings transfers if possible, as Bryan et al. (2010) showed commitment devices increase success. Use a visible tracker (e.g., a jar or app) to see progress.
   • Evidence: Research by Thaler and Benartzi (2004) in Journal of Political Economy on the "Save More Tomorrow" program demonstrated that gradual increases in savings (starting small) lead to higher adherence than large, immediate commitments.

---

Further Practical Strategies for Success

In addition to the tips provided earlier (tracking progress, rewarding small wins, preparing for setbacks, and leveraging social support), here are more research-backed strategies to enhance resolution adherence:

• Use Temptation Bundling: Pair a resolution with something enjoyable. For instance, only listen to a favorite audiobook while walking. Milkman et al. (2014) found this increased gym attendance by 51% in their study.
• Reframe Identity: Think of yourself as the person you want to become (e.g., "I’m a reader" instead of "I need to read more"). Walton and Cohen (2016) showed this mindset shift sustains motivation during challenges.
• Capitalize on Fresh Starts: If you miss the New Year’s momentum, use other milestones (e.g., first of the month, after a vacation) to restart. Dai et al. (2014) found these temporal landmarks renew commitment.
• Limit Decision Fatigue: Simplify choices related to your resolution. For example, plan weekly meals in advance to avoid daily decisions about healthy eating. Baumeister et al. (1998) in Journal of Personality and Social Psychology showed that reducing trivial decisions preserves willpower for important goals.

---

Summary of All Suggested Resolutions

To consolidate, here are all the resolutions provided across both responses, each designed to be achievable and sustainable based on empirical evidence:

1. Daily Movement (Walking or Light Exercise): Small, consistent physical activity (e.g., 5,000 steps daily) for health and mood benefits.
2. Mindful Eating (Small Dietary Adjustments): Incremental changes like adding one vegetable serving daily instead of restrictive diets.
3. Daily Gratitude or Journaling: Writing 1-3 things you’re thankful for daily to boost mental well-being.
4. Improved Sleep Hygiene: Consistent bedtime routines (e.g., no screens 30 minutes before bed) for better rest.
5. Learning a Micro-Skill: Daily practice of a small skill (e.g., one new word) for cognitive growth.
6. Social Connection (Regular Check-Ins): Weekly outreach to loved ones for emotional health.
7. Reduce Digital Overload (Screen Time Limits): Limit recreational screen time to 1-2 hours daily for reduced stress.
8. Practice Micro-Acts of Kindness: One small kind act daily to increase happiness.
9. Financial Mindfulness (Small Savings Goals): Save $1-$5 weekly for financial security and reduced anxiety.

---

Conclusion

The success of New Year's resolutions is well-documented to depend on factors like specificity, realism, positive framing, intrinsic motivation, and strategic planning. Studies such as Norcross et al. (1988, 2002), Milkman et al. (2014), and Walton and Cohen (2016) underscore the importance of small, incremental goals, identity-based motivation, and behavioral strategies like temptation bundling and commitment devices. The additional resolutions—reducing digital overload, practicing kindness, and financial mindfulness—complement the earlier suggestions by addressing diverse aspects of well-being (mental health, social bonds, and financial stability), all while remaining achievable through micro-steps.

Beyond the resolutions and strategies listed, the "fresh start effect" and identity reframing offer powerful psychological tools to restart and sustain motivation.