Edgar Allan Poe: personality/temperament profile

 

Personality Overview of Edgar Allan Poe

Edgar Allan Poe (1809–1849) is often described as a melancholic, introspective, and deeply imaginative individual. His life was marked by personal tragedy, including the early loss of his parents, financial struggles, and the death of his beloved wife, Virginia. These experiences likely shaped his dark, brooding literary themes and his intense emotional depth. Poe was known to be highly intelligent, creative, and sensitive, but also prone to mood swings, self-destructive behavior (including struggles with alcoholism), and a sense of alienation from society. He was a perfectionist in his craft, with a sharp critical mind, but often faced interpersonal conflicts due to his abrasive and defensive nature.

Psychological and Personality Frameworks

1. Jungian Archetypes
   Poe likely embodies several Jungian archetypes, with the most prominent being:

   • The Shadow: Representing his inner darkness, obsession with death, and the macabre themes in his work.
   • The Sage: Reflecting his intellectual depth, analytical mind, and pursuit of hidden truths through his detective stories (e.g., "The Murders in the Rue Morgue").
   • The Orphan: Stemming from his early losses and lifelong feelings of abandonment and isolation.

2. Myers-Briggs 4-Letter Type
   Poe’s personality aligns closely with INFP (Introverted, Intuitive, Feeling, Perceiving). He was introspective, driven by personal values and emotions, imaginative, and often unstructured in his life, focusing on creative expression over practical concerns.

3. Myers-Briggs 2-Letter Type
   Using the simplified temperament model, Poe would likely be classified as NF (Intuitive-Feeling), which emphasizes idealism, empathy, and a focus on human potential and emotion.

4. Enneagram Type
   Poe fits well as an Enneagram Type 4 – The Individualist (with a possible 5-wing, "The Iconoclast"). Type 4s are introspective, emotionally deep, and often feel different or misunderstood, which mirrors Poe’s life and work. His focus on personal suffering, uniqueness, and melancholy aligns with this type.

5. New Personality Self-Portrait Styles
   Based on John Oldham’s personality styles, Poe likely exhibits a combination of the following:

   • Sensitive: Deeply emotional, introspective, and affected by personal losses.
   • Idiosyncratic: Unique in thought and expression, often living outside societal norms.
   • Mercurial: Prone to mood swings and intense emotional experiences.
   • Solitary: Often isolated, preferring his own company or small, intimate connections.
   • Serious: Focused on profound, often dark themes with little inclination for levity.
   • Additionally, Poe may exhibit traits of being socially awkward, as historical accounts suggest he struggled with social interactions and often came across as aloof or abrasive.

6. Temperament Type (4-Temperament Theory or 4-Humors Theory)
   Poe aligns most closely with the Melancholic temperament. Melancholics are introspective, sensitive, perfectionistic, and prone to sadness or depression, which matches Poe’s disposition and creative output. There might also be a blend of Phlegmatic traits due to his tendency toward withdrawal and introspection.

7. Possible Personality Disorders
   While it’s speculative to diagnose historical figures, Poe’s behavior and life suggest potential issues such as:

   • Depressive Disorder: Evident in his chronic melancholy and themes of despair.
   • Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD): Possible due to intense emotions, fear of abandonment, and self-destructive tendencies (e.g., alcoholism).
   • Avoidant Personality Disorder: Suggested by his social withdrawal and feelings of inadequacy or alienation.

8. Hierarchy of Basic Desires (Based on Steven Reiss’s Theory)
   Poe’s hierarchy of desires might prioritize:

   • Curiosity: A strong drive to explore the unknown, evident in his detective stories and fascination with mystery.
   • Idealism: A desire for meaning and beauty, often expressed through tragic romance and gothic aesthetics.
   • Status: A need for recognition as a literary genius, which he sought through his critical writings and poetry.

9. Hierarchy of Basic Values
   Poe’s values likely centered on:

   • Creativity and Self-Expression: Above all, his work prioritized artistic innovation.
   • Authenticity: A commitment to exploring true, often dark, human emotions.
   • Intimacy: A deep need for personal connection, seen in his devotion to his wife, Virginia.

10. Hierarchy of Basic Ideals (Not Desires)
    Poe’s ideals might include:

    • Truth: A pursuit of uncovering hidden or uncomfortable realities about life and death.
    • Beauty: An ideal of aesthetic perfection, often tinged with tragedy.
    • Justice: A subtle ideal in his detective stories, where truth and reason prevail.

11. Character Weaknesses or Flaws

    • Self-destructive tendencies (alcoholism and financial mismanagement).
    • Emotional volatility and difficulty maintaining stable relationships.
    • Tendency toward paranoia or defensiveness in professional critiques.

12. Possible Neurotic Defense Mechanisms

    • Sublimation: Channeling his inner turmoil and grief into creative works like "The Raven" and "Annabel Lee."
    • Repression: Burying painful emotions related to loss and abandonment, which surface in his dark themes.
    • Projection: Possibly attributing his own fears or flaws to characters or critics in his life.
    • Rationalization: Justifying self-destructive behaviors as necessary for his art or due to external circumstances.

13. Possible Trance States
    Poe might have experienced dissociative or trance-like states during intense creative periods, where he became deeply absorbed in his imagination. His use of alcohol could also have induced altered states of consciousness, contributing to his darker, more surreal writings.

14. Big Five Personality Dimensions

    • Openness to Experience: Extremely high, due to his creativity and fascination with the unusual.
    • Conscientiousness: Low to moderate, as he struggled with organization and financial stability despite being meticulous in his writing.
    • Extraversion: Low, given his introverted and solitary nature.
    • Agreeableness: Low, due to his often contentious relationships with peers and critics.
    • Neuroticism: Very high, reflecting emotional instability, anxiety, and depression.

15. Main NLP Meta-Programs (Referring to "The Sourcebook of Magic" by L. Michael Hall)
    Based on neuro-linguistic programming (NLP) meta-programs, Poe might exhibit:

    • Toward vs. Away-From Motivation: Likely "Away-From," as much of his work seems driven by avoidance of pain, loss, and despair rather than pursuit of happiness.
    • Internal vs. External Reference: Strongly "Internal," relying on his own feelings and imagination rather than external validation.
    • Global vs. Specific Thinking: More "Global," focusing on overarching themes of death and mystery rather than minute details (though his detective stories show some "Specific" traits).
    • Mismatch vs. Match: Likely "Mismatch," often seeing what is wrong or different, which fueled his critical writings and dark perspectives.

Sources

1 The Sourcebook of Magic by L. Michael Hall Ph.D. and Barbara Belnap M.S.W.

2 Personality Plus Revised and Expanded Edition by Florence Littauer

3 New Personality Self-Portrait by John M. Oldham, M.D. and Lois B. Morris

4 Personality Plus by Florence Littauer

5 Jungian Archetypes by Robin Robertson

6 The Enneagram and NLP by Anne Linden and Murray Spalding

7 Personality Puzzle by Florence Littauer and Marita Littauer

text, i-207...