Queen Elizabeth I of England (1533–1603): personality/temperament profile

 Queen Elizabeth I of England (1533–1603) famously rejected numerous marriage proposals throughout her reign, including proposals from King Philip II of Spain, despite his wealth, power, and influence as one of the most dominant monarchs of 16th-century Europe. This decision had significant personal, political, and diplomatic implications.

Traits and Characteristics of Queen Elizabeth I:

Queen Elizabeth I was a highly complex historical figure, known for her intelligence, independence, and political acumen. Below is a breakdown of her personality and traits, including possible strengths and flaws:

Strengths and Positive Traits:

1. Intelligence and Education:

   • Elizabeth was highly educated, fluent in multiple languages, and an exceptional strategist.
   • She understood the political landscape of Europe and used diplomacy and her unmarried status as tools of statecraft.

2. Independence:

   • Known as the "Virgin Queen," Elizabeth cherished her independence and refused to be dominated by a husband, especially in an era when women were expected to submit to their male counterparts.

3. Resilience:

   • Her early life was marked by danger and adversity, including her imprisonment under her half-sister, Queen Mary I. This fostered an enduring resilience.

4. Charisma:

   • Elizabeth was a brilliant orator and maintained an image of herself as a benevolent, almost divine ruler (the idea of the "Gloriana").

Flaws and Vices:

1. Emotional Guardedness:

   • She was known to keep people at arm's length, often avoiding deep personal relationships.

2. Manipulative Tendencies:

   • Elizabeth sometimes used her suitors for political leverage, stringing them along without committing to marriage.

3. Uncertainty and Pragmatism:

   • While pragmatic, she could be indecisive, especially when faced with military or religious conflicts.

4. Authoritarian Streak:

   • Elizabeth demanded loyalty and brooked no dissent, which sometimes alienated her advisors or subjects.

---

MMPI (Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory) Analysis

The MMPI is a psychological assessment tool used to evaluate personality traits and psychopathology. Based on Queen Elizabeth I's traits and historical characteristics, here are the MMPI scales she might score high or low on:

Scales She Would Score High On:

1. Scale 5: Masculinity-Femininity (Mf)

   • Elizabeth would score high on this scale, as she exhibited traits considered atypical for women in her time, such as assertiveness, independence, and leadership.

2. Scale 6: Paranoia (Pa)

   • Her guardedness and mistrust of others, shaped by her tumultuous upbringing, suggest she may score high on this scale. She was often suspicious of plots against her rule.

3. Scale 8: Schizophrenia (Sc)

   • While Elizabeth did not exhibit psychosis, this scale also measures unconventional thinking. Her visionary and unconventional political maneuvers might elevate her score slightly.

4. Scale 9: Hypomania (Ma)

   • Her energy, charisma, and ability to inspire others suggest a high score on this scale, reflecting her dynamism and high activity levels as a monarch.

Scales She Would Score Low On:

1. Scale 1: Hypochondriasis (Hs)

   • Elizabeth rarely exhibited undue concern about her health, showing resilience and strength despite the physical challenges of her era.

2. Scale 2: Depression (D)

   • Although she faced adversity, she showed little evidence of prolonged depressive episodes, maintaining a positive and authoritative demeanor.

3. Scale 7: Psychasthenia (Pt)

   • This scale measures anxiety and obsessive tendencies. While cautious, Elizabeth's decisiveness and confidence suggest a low score here.

4. Scale 0: Social Introversion (Si)

   • Elizabeth was charismatic and socially adept, suggesting a low score on social introversion.

---

Summary of Queen Elizabeth I's MMPI Profile:

If Queen Elizabeth I were assessed using the MMPI, her profile might indicate a strong, independent, and charismatic personality with some elevated levels of guardedness and unconventional thinking. She would likely score high on scales related to assertiveness, leadership, and political acumen.

Political Context of Rejecting King Philip II:

Elizabeth's refusal to marry Philip II was a carefully calculated decision. Accepting such a marriage could have:

• Compromised England’s sovereignty, as Philip was already a dominant Catholic ruler.
• Sparked further religious and political tensions in Protestant England.
• Undermined Elizabeth's authority as a female monarch.

By remaining unmarried, Elizabeth maintained control over her reign and used her unmarried status as a diplomatic bargaining tool, leveraging proposals to secure alliances without committing to them. This decision solidified her image as the "Virgin Queen," symbolizing loyalty to England above all else.

In addition:

Based on historical accounts of Queen Elizabeth I, here is my personality analysis:

Jungian archetypes: Primary - The Ruler, Secondary - The Sage

Myers-Briggs 4 letter type: ENTJ (The Commander)
Myers-Briggs 2 letter type: NT (Rational)

Enneagram: Type 8w7 (The Challenger with Seven Wing)

New Personality Self-Portrait Styles:

• Primary: Self-confident, Vigilant
• Secondary: Dramatic, Aggressive
• Tertiary: Serious, Conscientious

Four Temperaments: Choleric-Melancholic blend

Possible Personality Patterns:

• Narcissistic traits
• Obsessive-compulsive traits

Basic Desires Hierarchy:

1. Power/Control
2. Independence
3. Knowledge
4. Recognition
5. Order

Basic Values Hierarchy:

1. Duty to England
2. Protestant faith
3. Independence
4. Intelligence
5. Strength

Basic Ideals Hierarchy:

1. National sovereignty
2. Religious stability
3. Cultural advancement
4. Political mastery
5. Personal autonomy

Character Flaws:

• Pride
• Vanity
• Indecisiveness in personal matters
• Trust issues
• Emotional suppression

Neurotic Defense Mechanisms:

• Sublimation (channeling emotional energy into ruling)
• Rationalization
• Reaction Formation

Big Five Dimensions:

• High Conscientiousness
• High Openness
• Moderate Extraversion
• Low Agreeableness
• Moderate Neuroticism

Main NLP Meta-Programs:

• Proactive
• Options
• Internal reference
• Global pattern
• Away-from motivation pattern

For relationship matches:
Good match: INTP or ISTP male (would complement her decisiveness while providing analytical support)
Bad match: ESFJ or ENFJ male (too emotionally demanding)

Famous person good match: Sir Francis Drake (explorer, tactical thinker)

Famous person bad match: Philip II of Spain (too controlling, competing power needs)

Queen Elizabeth I’s rejection of marriage to King Philip of Spain, despite his wealth and power, can be understood through various political and personal considerations. One significant reason was her desire to maintain England's sovereignty and independence. Marrying Philip, a staunch Catholic, could have jeopardized the Protestant Reformation established in England, leading to potential religious conflicts and loss of power [4].

Additionally, Elizabeth was wary of the political implications of such a union. A marriage to Philip would have tied England closely to Spain, limiting her ability to navigate alliances in a volatile European landscape. This concern for national autonomy reflects her understanding of the psychological need for control and independence in leadership, which is crucial for maintaining a stable state [2][6].

Moreover, Elizabeth was known for her strong will and desire to remain unmarried to preserve her power as a ruler. The idea of a woman marrying and potentially being subordinate to a husband conflicted with her image as the "Virgin Queen" who ruled in her own right [3][5]. This personal conviction against marriage, especially to a foreign monarch, highlights her commitment to her role and responsibilities as a monarch over personal desires.

In summary, Queen Elizabeth I's rejection of King Philip was rooted in her commitment to England's sovereignty, her strategic political considerations, and her personal beliefs about female autonomy and power [1][4].

Sources 

1 Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Text Revision Dsm-5-tr 5th Edition by American Psychiatric Association 

2 the Liberal Mind by Lyle H. Rossiter Jr., M.D. 

3 Man in the Trap by Elsworth F. Baker  

4 The Personality Disorders Treatment Planner: Includes DSM-5 Updates (PracticePlanners) 2nd Edition by Neil R. Bockian, Julia C. Smith, and Arthur E. Jongsma Jr.  

5 Criminological and Forensic Psychology Third Edition by Helen Gavin  

6 The Psychology of Freedom by Peter R. Breggin, M.D. 

Story ideas for Leslie (with Elizabeth I's personality):

1. Modern corporate CEO Leslie navigating power politics while maintaining independence
2. Leslie as a brilliant but isolated tech entrepreneur dealing with trust issues
3. Space colony commander Leslie making tough decisions while hiding personal vulnerabilities
4. University president Leslie reforming an institution while struggling with personal relationships