Surgery and drugs for gender change in children is a failed experiment

Here are some key points and evidence often cited by critics who argue that surgical and drug therapy gender-affirming care for children is a failed social experiment:


Desistance Rates: Critics point to studies suggesting that a significant number of children who experience gender dysphoria may eventually identify with their sex assigned at birth without medical intervention. They argue that early medical treatments might be unnecessary and could lead to regret later in life [1].


Ethical and Consent Issues: There are concerns about whether children and adolescents can fully understand and consent to the long-term implications of medical treatments like hormone therapy and surgeries. Critics argue that these decisions should be made with more caution and consideration.


Long-Term Impact: The long-term physical and psychological effects of gender-affirming treatments in children are not yet fully understood. Critics worry about potential health risks associated with hormone therapy and surgeries performed at a young age [1].


Psychological and Social Pressures: Some believe that societal and peer pressures might influence children's decisions regarding gender identity, and that these children might benefit more from counseling and support rather than immediate medical interventions.


Legislative Actions: Several states and countries have enacted laws restricting or banning gender-affirming care for minors, reflecting concerns about the appropriateness and safety of these treatments for children.


Systematic Reviews: Recent systematic reviews conducted by public health authorities in countries like Finland, Sweden, and England have concluded that the risk/benefit ratio of youth gender transition ranges from unknown to unfavorable. These reviews suggest that the evidence does not support the notion that gender-affirming care is net beneficial for adolescents [1].

Sources

1 Current Concerns About Gender-Affirming Therapy in Adolescents

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11930-023-00358-x

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Vincent Van Gogh: personality/temperament profile

  Analysis of Vincent van Gogh Based on Traits and MMPI Scales Brief Overview of Vincent van Gogh's Traits and Characteristics: Vincent van Gogh (1853–1890) was a post-impressionist painter known for his emotional intensity and unique artistic style. His life was marked by immense creativity but also by profound struggles with mental and physical health. Traits and Characteristics: Strengths and Positive Traits: Remarkable artistic talent and vision. Deep sensitivity and emotional depth. Passionate and determined (created over 2,000 artworks, often in short periods of time). Profound love for nature, spirituality, and humanity (reflected in his works). Flaws and Vices: Intense mood swings and impulsivity. Social withdrawal and difficulty maintaining relationships. Obsession with his craft, leading to neglect of basic needs. Mental Health Issues: Possible diagnosis of bipolar disorder or major depressive disorder . Hallucinations and delusions (suggestive ...
Read more

Princess Diana: personality/temperament profile

  Princess Diana: Personality Assessment Based on MMPI Scales Traits and Characteristics: Princess Diana, also known as Diana, Princess of Wales (1961-1997), was one of the most famous and beloved figures of the 20th century. Her personality was marked by warmth, empathy, and vulnerability, but she also struggled with emotional difficulties and personal challenges. Key Traits: Compassionate and empathetic: Deeply engaged in humanitarian work Highly emotional and sensitive: Struggled with feelings of rejection and loneliness Charismatic and charming: Loved by the public for her authenticity Impulsive and rebellious: Struggled with royal traditions and often acted against strict protocols Insecure and self-critical: Battled self-esteem issues Flaws and Struggles: Mental health issues: Struggled with depression and anxiety Eating disorders: Publicly admitted to suffering from bulimia Emotional distress: Felt isolated in her marriage and personal life Impulsivity: En...
Read more

SYNCHRONISTIC THEISTIC MONISM: an Ebook that explains Tarot, I Ching, and more

  Synchronistic Theistic Monism , a New Worldview   by Michael Perel,M.D. Synchronistic Theistic Monism explains Tarot , I Ching ,  psychic abilities , and more. Summary: The cosmos: God created a system that makes divination possible, such as Tarot and I Ching. Scientific Facts: The cosmos began 13.8 billion years ago with the Big Bang , a singular event confirmed by cosmic background radiation . It exhibits fine-tuning—e.g., the gravitational constant ’s precision suggests intelligent design. It’s interconnected, from quantum entanglement to ecological webs , forming a holistic system. This origin, precision, and unity point to a purposeful creation by a divine intelligence . Conclusion: God intentionally crafted a holistic cosmos as part of His plan. From an eternal vision, God willed a purposeful design into existence, systematically integrating its parts into an interconnected whole governed by axioms and laws.  Axioms and Laws:  God’s Nature: God is omnis...
Read more