Mental illness: an objective definition

 To find an objective definition of "mental illness":

(1) Reduce the concept to its perceptual level roots and basic fundamental axioms/principles:


Perceptual level roots:

  • Physical states/conditions of the brain
  • Observable behaviors and experiences (thoughts, emotions, perceptions)
  • Environmental/social factors

Basic axioms/principles:

  • The mind arises from the brain's biological processes
  • Thoughts, emotions, behaviors are caused by neurological activity
  • Brains can malfunction, just like other biological organs
  • Genetic and environmental factors influence brain development/function

(2) Additional intermediate steps/principles:

  • Certain patterns of brain dysfunction correlate with specific clusters of abnormal thoughts, behaviors, emotional states
  • These dysfunctional patterns can cause significant distress/impairment
  • Mental disorders have descriptive diagnostic criteria based on observable symptoms
  • Etiology involves complex gene-environment interactions

(3) Measurable characteristics:

  • Deviation from normal/healthy brain function
  • Presence of specific cognitive, emotional, behavioral symptoms
  • Functional impairment across life domains
  • Symptoms cause clinically significant distress

(4) Definition:
Mental illness refers to a disorder of brain function characterized by clinically significant deviation from normal cognitive, emotional and/or behavioral processes. It is manifested by impaired psychological functioning causing significant distress and/or disability across multiple life domains. Mental illnesses are defined by their descriptive symptomatic criteria, reflect underlying dysfunction in the biological, psychological and/or social processes involved in mental functioning, and are influenced by genetic and environmental factors.


The criteria for an objective definition are:

  1. Based on facts/observations instead of opinions/biases
  2. Precisely defines the concept using essential characteristics
  3. Distinguishes it from other concepts based on differentiae
  4. Is universal and generalizable

This definition meets those criteria by:

  1. Grounding it in observable neurological and behavioral phenomena
  2. Specifying the key characteristics of dysfunction and impairment
  3. Differentiating mental illness from healthy psychological functioning
  4. Not being restricted to any specific culture, time period or context

While comprehensive, this is still a general definition that captures the universal core features of mental illness based on our current neuroscientific understanding. It is an objective definition to the extent of our present knowledge.



To expand further on the objective definition of mental illness:


Perceptual Roots:

  • Observed problems with cognition (thinking, memory, perception)
  • Abnormal emotional experiences (depression, anxiety, etc.)
  • Dysfunctional behaviors (social withdrawal, self-harm, etc.)
  • Disturbances in neurological processes (neurotransmission, brain activity, etc.)

Basic Axioms/Principles:

  • The brain is the physical basis of the mind
  • Mental processes arise from neuronal activity and brain circuits
  • Disruptions to these neurological processes manifest as psychological symptoms
  • These disruptions have biological, psychological and social causal factors

Intermediate Steps/Principles:

  • Specific patterns of symptoms cluster together into syndromes
  • These syndromes are classified into mental disorder categories
  • Categories are defined by diagnostic criteria and clinical descriptions
  • Disorders exist on a spectrum of severity based on level of impairment
  • Treatment aims to correct underlying neurobiological dysfunction

Measurable Characteristics:

  • Clinically significant cognitive/behavioral deviations from norms
  • Patterns matching established diagnostic criteria
  • Functional impairment measured by symptom severity
  • Observable distress across life domains (work, relationships etc.)
  • Neurological markers associating with specific disorders

Definition:
A mental illness is a disorder characterized by a clinically significant disturbance in/impairment of an individual's cognition, emotional regulation, or behavior. This disturbance/impairment reflects underlying dysfunction in the biological, psychological or developmental processes involved in mental functioning. Mental illnesses are defined by patterns of persistent and impairing symptoms, categorized by validated diagnostic criteria, and exist on a continuum based on severity of functional impairment across major life activities. The expression of mental illness results from complex interactions of genetic vulnerability and environmental factors.


This definition meets the criteria for objectivity by:

  1. Grounding it in observable data about behavior, cognition, neurobiology
  2. Precisely defining key characteristics like deviance, dysfunction, impairment
  3. Differentiating disorders from normal psychological phenomena
  4. Not being culturally/temporally bound - applies universally

While still a general definition, it comprehensively captures the core features of psychopathology based on current scientific understanding, defining mental illness in terms of objectively verifiable criteria without undue subjectivity, mysticism or pseudoscience. It can be expanded further as knowledge increases.



Here are some additional details to further expand on the objective definition of mental illness:


Perceptual Roots:

  • Observable changes in behavior patterns (social, occupational, self-care)
  • Reported subjective experiences (perceptions, thoughts, emotions)
  • Measurable cognitive deficits (attention, memory, executive function)
  • Neurological signs (EEG, brain imaging, neurological exam findings)

Basic Axioms/Principles:

  • Mind and behavior arise from brain structure and function
  • Genes and biology interact with environment/experiences
  • Disrupting underlying biological processes disrupts mental processes
  • Complex disorders have multifactorial bio-psycho-social causes

Intermediate Steps/Principles:

  • Linking symptom patterns to specific neurobiological dysfunctions
  • Validating diagnostic constructs against biomarkers and illness course
  • Understanding how genetic, neural, cognitive, behavioral levels interact
  • Developing etiological models based on risk factors and causal mechanisms
  • Determining thresholds for clinical significance and need for care

Measurable Characteristics:

  • Reliable assessment of symptoms via clinical interviews/testing
  • Biomarker measures (genes, neuroimaging, neurochemistry)
  • Standardized rating scales for severity and functional impact
  • Measurable cognitive/emotional/behavioral deficits vs. norms
  • Statistical deviation from population base rates

Definition:
Mental illnesses are clinically significant disorders of/impairments in cognition, emotional regulation, or behavior reflecting dysfunction in underlying psychological, biological, or developmental processes involved in mental functioning. They are defined by validated diagnostic criteria specifying characteristic symptom patterns, disability/distress, and biomarker correlates when available. Mental disorders exist on a continuum of severity, based on degrees of functional impairment across major life activities. Their etiologies involve complex gene-environment interactions, with biological vulnerability and environmental stressors as key risk factors. Despite diverse presentations, all mental illnesses share a common core feature of disordered/impaired neural processes giving rise to dysfunctional psychological phenomena.


This comprehensive definition maintains objectivity by:

  1. Grounding the concept in observables (symptoms, biomarkers, behaviors)
  2. Precisely specifying characteristics like dysfunction, disability, deviation
  3. Differentiation from normal phenomena using measurable thresholds
  4. Capturing universal features based on neuroscience and clinical science

While still a general definition, it incorporates current evidence across disciplines to objectify mental illness as a construct, free from mysticism, pseudoscience, or pure subjectivity. It can continue being refined as the scientific understanding advances.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Just War, An Objective Definition

  Just War Objective Definition: Perceptual Level Roots and Basic Fundamental Axioms: Human beings have inherent rights to life, liberty, and security.  This is a fundamental axiom of just war theory, rooted in the observation that all humans share these basic needs and desires. States have a responsibility to protect their citizens from harm.  This responsibility stems from the social contract between the state and its citizens, where citizens give up some individual freedoms in exchange for the state's protection. War is a last resort.  This means that all other peaceful means of resolving a conflict must be exhausted before resorting to war. This axiom recognizes the destructive nature of war and the importance of seeking peaceful solutions whenever possible. War must be fought with proportionality.  This means that the force used must be proportionate to the threat posed by the enemy. This axiom aims to minimize unnecessary suffering and destruction. War must be fought with dis
Read more

The Impact of Reduced Working Hours (1) on the Economy: A Free Market Analysis

  The Impact of Reduced Working Hours on the Economy: A Free Market Analysis  In a free market economy, where supply and demand dictate prices and production, a reduction in the number of hours worked per day by workers can have significant consequences across the entire economic system. This essay will explore the chain reaction that starts with reduced working hours and culminates in a decrease in the standard of living for the average worker. Reduced Working Hours and Aggregate Productivity: When workers put in fewer hours, the total output produced naturally decreases. This decline in aggregate productivity directly impacts the overall supply of goods and services in the economy. With fewer goods and services available, the scarcity principle dictates that their prices will rise. Decreased Aggregate Production and Aggregate Supply: The reduced output caused by fewer working hours directly translates to a decrease in aggregate production. This decline in production further exacerbat
Read more

11 Commandments of Rationality

People who break/disobey many of these 11 commandments, like George Floyd did, tend to have a shorter life expectancy rate. Honoring him is like honoring the bad for being the bad. 1) be a producer and not a parasite (moocher or looter) 2) don't be addicted to street drugs 3) don't overdose on drugs 4) don't be an alcoholic or smoke  5) don't be a criminal 6) don't physically fight the cops 7) be rational: follow reality and reason and not emotionalism, subjectivism, or fantasies, and adhere to rational principles as the guide to decisions and actions 8) be healthy, wealthy, wise, honest, independent, prudent, with high self-esteem, and don't compromise your integrity 9) pursue knowledge of reality and objective truth 10) pursue rational self-interest, follow individualism, limited government, and capitalism 11) initiation of force and violation of natural rights is prohibited, while the perfect right of self defense is allowed Here is a more elegant and refined
Read more